Tánaiste says border poll ‘not appropriate or right at this time’

Tánaiste says border poll ‘not appropriate or right at this time’
Leo Varadkar comments, © PA Wire/PA Images

By Rebecca Black, PA

An Irish border poll would “not be appropriate or right” at this time, the Tánaiste has said.

However, Leo Varadkar has called for the tests around when Northern Ireland Secretary Brandon Lewis should call a referendum on Irish unity to be clarified.

The Tánaiste, who is set to become Taoiseach in December, described the aspiration to a united Ireland as a “legitimate one”.


But he added: “I don’t think it’s appropriate or right at this time.

A section of the Irish border at Carlingford Lough between County Down in Northern Ireland and Co Louth in the Irish Republic (PA)

“Fundamentally, because I think we need to get the Assembly and Executive up and running.


“We need to resolve the issues around protocol. And I think that can be done.”

Mr Varadkar told BBC Northern Ireland’s Sunday Politics programme he did not believe the tests laid out in the Belfast Agreement had been met.

He said while Sinn Féin emerged as the largest party for the first time in the Northern Ireland Assembly, they did not gain any seats, and said the number of MLAs who want a united Ireland was lower now than in the previous mandate.

“A border poll at this stage would be both divisive and defeated, and that wouldn’t be a good outcome for anyone,” he said.


In terms of the outcome of any future border poll, he said 50 per cent plus one was not desirable.

(left to right) Eamon Ryan Minister for the Environment Climate and Communications, Taoiseach Micheál Martin and Tánaiste Leo Varadkar (PA)

“You’d end up having a very large minority of people being brought into a united Ireland they didn’t want to be part of,” he said.

“What I would like to try and achieve is as big a majority as possible.

“But I do think one thing we should do is clarify the tests around when a border poll can and should happen.

“Because I doubt any Secretary of State would make that decision without consulting the Prime Minister and the Cabinet, and it doesn’t really say clearly how that test is applied as, to whether there is consistent public support for it.

“Is the Secretary of State supposed to look at the Assembly election results, is it independent polls, what is it, and I think that’s something that really ought to be clarified and could be clarified.”

Meanwhile, Mr Varadkar spoke of his respect for DUP leader Sir Jeffrey Donaldson as “open and engaging” and someone he believes he can work with.

DUP leader Sir Jeffrey Donaldson (PA)

“But that’s not in any way to be naive about it, he is someone who has very firm and very strong views, I’m not saying I am going to persuade him of my views but he’s definitely someone who I believe we can work with, someone I respect and I hope to see him as a minister in the Executive soon,” he said.

Mr Varadkar is set to become Taoiseach again later this year under the terms of the government deal agreed between Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil and the Green Party.

He has insisted he is “not particularly worried” about opinion polls which put Sinn Féin well ahead of Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil in the Republic, insisting they don’t predict the outcome of elections, pointing to the results of the last Irish general election.

“It doesn’t unduly bother me… I know that opinion polls don’t predict the outcome of elections but even if you do look at those polls, one thing they do show – and we’re midterm at the moment – is the combined support of the government parties is between 40 and 50 per cent,” he said.

“That says to me that it is possible for this Government to be re-elected, and obviously I would like Fine Gael to be able to be part of the next government and to be the strongest party in that Government but the way we achieve that is not by focusing on Sinn Féin in my view, but it’s by focusing on the things that people care about the most.”